Weekend Film Recommendation: The Stars Look Down


The last remaining British coal mine closed in December, bringing a way of life to an end. My Welsh ancestors were among those who worked in this industry, giving movies about life in the pit a special power for me. The movie about British mining towns that Americans are most likely to recall is the John Ford classic How Green Was My Valley, but I like this week’s film recommendation even more: The Stars Look Down.

Fans of prior RBC film recommendation Night Train to Munich will be justifiably excited to watch this movie, which was made immediately before it by the same director (Sir Carol Reed) and stars (Michael Redgrave and Margaret Lockwood). But the two films otherwise could not be more different. The Stars Look Down is a working class drama with fewer light moments and a more downbeat final act than Night Train to Munich, making it a much more weighty work.

The plot: In a grim Northern English town, miners toil in Scupper Flats, seeking to extract the coal from the earth without breaking through to the millions of tons of water that threatens their existence. The Fenwicks are like any other family in town, except that their elder son Davey (Redgrave) has earnt a scholarship. Davey hopes that a proper education will enable him to become an effective political advocate for exploited miners. But he is diverted from his plans by his love of a local lass named Jenny (Lockwood), whose desire to immediately escape the miserable trappings of working class life lead Davey to sacrifice his educational opportunities. Meanwhile, his erstwhile friend and Jenny’s former beau Joe Gowlan (Emlyn Williams) also tries to make his way in the world, but does so by betraying his roots, with disastrous consequences.

Redgrave and Lockwood are both terrific here, playing characters utterly different than the light-hearted lovers of Night Train to Munch (and before that, the charming couple in peril in another RBC recommendation The Lady Vanishes). I was particularly impressed by Atwood’s willingness to break away from being everyone’s sweetheart and instead play a petty, grasping human being who is at the same time sympathetic (after all, she is only what poverty made her). Character actor Emlyn Williams also gives one of his best performances, starting out as somewhat comic and then devolving into unmitigated avarice and sociopathy. Under Reed’s direction, the supporting performances are also strong, most affectingly Nancy Price’s portrayal of Davey’s hard-bitten mother.

sld A.J. Cronin adapted his own novel to co-write the script with J.B. Williams, and it’s appropriately unromantic about how cruel working class people can be to each other and how ambivalent they sometimes are about one of their own rising to a different class. The only weakness of the script is the opening and closing voiceover narration, something that worked very well in Reed’s best film, The Third Man, but seems heavy-handed here. But it’s an easily ignored flaw in an otherwise dramatic and powerful script.

Last but not least, the special effects and camerawork in the mining scenes are extraordinarily vivid. Reed knew how to draw the audience into the lives of his characters, even when their fear of the horrors of the pit would make them want to pull away. The result is a meaty working class drama with shattering emotional impact.

p.s. One person who experienced that impact was my co-blogger Michael O’Hare’s mother, the sculptor Berta Margoulies (1907-1996). Her 1942 piece, Mine Disaster, in the permanent collection of the Whitney Museum of American Art, was directly inspired by The Stars Look Down.

Image Courtesy of the Whitney Museum
Image Courtesy of the Whitney Museum

Author: Keith Humphreys

Keith Humphreys is the Esther Ting Memorial Professor of Psychiatry at Stanford University and an Honorary Professor of Psychiatry at Kings College London. His research, teaching and writing have focused on addictive disorders, self-help organizations (e.g., breast cancer support groups, Alcoholics Anonymous), evaluation research methods, and public policy related to health care, mental illness, veterans, drugs, crime and correctional systems. Professor Humphreys' over 300 scholarly articles, monographs and books have been cited over thirteen thousand times by scientific colleagues. He is a regular contributor to Washington Post and has also written for the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Monthly, San Francisco Chronicle, The Guardian (UK), The Telegraph (UK), Times Higher Education (UK), Crossbow (UK) and other media outlets.

11 thoughts on “Weekend Film Recommendation: The Stars Look Down”

  1. I didn't realize all mines were now closed. Years ago I went to the Big Pit Museum in Wales not long after it opened. Fascinating tour led by a former miner who took great pride in his mine.

    As for the movie a great film but a real downer. But as you say the cast is wonderful but I don't think I could watch it again.

  2. Michael Redgrave gave some of the finest screen performances ever, including this underwatched film. The Browning Version and Dead of Night would be at the top of the list. The Wonders in the Dark website is an advocate for movie I had never heard of, Thunder Rock, particularly Redgrave's performance. https://wondersinthedark.wordpress.com/2008/10/17

    But I really don't see Scandinavia as a pit pony.

  3. I consider The Browning Version his best, and also among the best in the history of British cinema. Overpowering.

    1. I love The Browning Version. Indeed Redgrave's best role. His emotional rollercoaster is impressive. One of my favorite films. His scene with the boy giving him that inscribed book is memorable. And a wonderful ending.

  4. Speaking of Welsh coal mining October 21 will be the 50th anniversary of the Aberfan disaster.

    1. You are right of course, a horror not unlike what the film portrays and what inspired Mike's mother.

Comments are closed.