Brendan Buck is Chief Communications Advisor to Speaker of the House Paul Ryan. Last week â€“ Was it only last week? â€“ Buck got in hot water because he falsely denied that House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy had said that Donald Trump and Rep. Dana Rohrabacher were being paid by Russia. When initially confronted, Buck flatly stated: â€œThat never happened.â€ Confronted with the existence of a tape, Buck shifted gears to say that Rep. McCarthy was merely joking.
Iâ€™m glad Buck was called out for his lie. In fairness, this wasnâ€™t entirely a lie. McCarthy was sort of joking. Of course, Buckâ€™s comment wasnâ€™t entirely truthful, either. The joke â€“ to the extent it was a joke â€“ rested on the accurate premise that President Trump and Rep. Rohrabacher are weirdly close to Vladimir Putin in a way that demands further scrutiny.
But hereâ€™s the real irony. Buck was humiliated over a lie that was far less significant â€“ and really less of a lie â€“ than many policy statements emerging from his own office that receive far less attention.
If you tell a verified lie about some political scandal, you are in trouble in Washington. You canâ€™t say â€œI did not have sex with that woman,â€ or â€œI did not have communications with the Russiansâ€ without consequence. But if you lie about policy â€“ for example to say that having Medicaid is no better than being uninsured, or that you are expanding access while leaving 23 million people without health insurance â€“ youâ€™ll usually get a pass. The disparate response to political lies and policy lies is one cause andÂ symptom of our broken politics.
More here on policy lies in AHCA….