Berkeley’s Task Force on Intercollegiate Athletics (TFIA)Â has submitted its reportÂ on what to do about an enterprise that soaks up tens of millions of dollars of subsidy each year while the university as a whole is being asked to eat almost $200m of budget cuts (see the TFIA assignment below). It’s appropriate to thank the members for the time they spent on this project. I wish it were possible to recognize their efforts as consequential or useful, but no such luck.Â My expectations were modest, but this result dashes even my cautious hopes, and as I know several of the members to be smart people with the best intentions, it saddens me to say so. Eleven members, working for almost a year, have come up with five single-spaced pages of content (no, this is not the executive summary, and it is not a memo boiled down for Donald Trump), and one big table of financials uncritically assembled from IA’s annual NCAA P/L reports.
A bitter irony is the appendix listing (without links to access any of them) five previous TFIAs, from 1991,â€™92,â€™99,2000 and 2010. Isnâ€™t a standard definition of insanity â€œdoing the same thing again and again expecting a different resultâ€?