June 12, 2006
Haditha: Warbloggers in denial
There are two possibilities I'm having trouble disambiguating. Either the Haditha incident has driven the warbloggers morally insane, or it has driven them insane, period.
Here are the facts as now known:
Civilians in Haditha were killed by Marines last November after a Marine was killed by an IED.
The first investigation cleared the soldiers of any wrongdoing, and found that the civilians had been killed by a bomb. A Marine spokesman called accounts of a massacre "aqi [al Qaeda Iraq] propaganda."
Time Magazine got hold of a videotape of some of the events, and supplied it to the Defense Department in January. A second investigation found that the civilians had been killed by Marines, but as "collateral damage" rather than deliberately.
But discrepant testimony in that second investigation led to two more investigations, one of the incident itself and one of the after-action reporting process. Last month, Cong. Jack Murtha, a former Marine colonel, a Democrat, and now a critic of the war, spoke out about the incident, based apparently on information from the investigation. (Murtha is known to retain strong sources of information within the military.) He said that Marines had "killed innocent civilians in cold blood."
Time reports that in the course of the two current investigations, the Marines involved have changed their stories. Time also reports that there are incriminating photos, taken by the Marines in the incident but not supplied to the initial after-action reporting process.
The investigation into the incident has now issued a preliminary report, which was shown to several Senators and Representatives by DoD. Several of them have spoken in public about what the report says. None has contradicted Murtha on the substance, or criticized him for speaking out. Rep. John Kline, another retired Marine colonel, a Republican, and a supporter of the war told Time "This was a small number of Marines who fired directly on civilians and killed them." He also said "There's no doubt that the Marines allegedly involved in doing thisthey lied about it," and "They certainly tried to cover it up."
In response, the warbloggers have been ranting, quibbling, and denouncing Murtha and the press. (James Joyner of Outside the Beltway, himself a hawk, documents and deplores some of the more hysterical terms thrown at Murtha, including "dishonorable" and "traitor.") They have resolutely ignored the fact that none of the Republican hawks who have seen the report seems to share their viewpoint. Greyhawk at Mudville Gazette, to whom Glenn Reynolds links uncritically, says that it's wrong to call the massacre an "unprovoked attack," because the killing of the Marine was a provocation. So even if the killings were unjustified, they weren't unprovoked. He then says (and this is where we enter clinical territory):
Let's further illustrate this point. You and I are in a crowded room. Suddenly I throw a punch, and hit you quite squarely in the jaw. You go down but arise quickly, though quite shaken, and immediately throw a punch at me. I'm ready though, so I duck, and you light up the young lady standing behind me, sending her to the carpet.No doubt at this point you are quite remorseful, but there's no one in the room who could reasonably accuse you of having launched an unprovoked attack on the young lady in question. Yes, you punched her. Yes, you were acting in anger. Yes, you lost control. But as the guy who struck first then avoided your retaliation, sane people might think I deserve most of the blame.
Unless, of course, your response was the entire point of my actions in the first place. And if the room is full of my friends who are quite willing to go along, you had best start backing towards the door. Because you hit a girl, you sumbitch. One who had done absolutely nothing to you, so it was unprovoked.
Oh by the way, Jimmy says he heard her turn you down when you asked her for a date five minutes ago.
But of course the hypothetical party situation is analogous, not to massacre, but to genuine "collateral damage": a bystander is hit by a punch intended for the aggressor in a fight. That has absolutely nothing to do with what seems to have actually happened: a Marine was killed, and some of his buddies lost it and went from house to house killing unresisting civilians.
Greyhawk then spends some more words and adrenaline ranting on about the use of "unprovoked," and concludes with a violent fantasy concerning the "senior defense official" who talked to Time.
Reynolds also links to what he calls a "post-mortem on Haditha coverage" by Mary Katherine Ham of Townhall.com. Ham points out that Time got some details wrong in its account of the provenance of the videotape that re-started the investigation, and quotes the defense attorneys in the case and other sources sympathetic to the Marines likely to be facing trial, who alternate between casting doubt on the sequence of events and making excuses for the misconduct that didn't occur.
What Reynolds and his linkees have in common is that they attribute all the accusations of misconduct to Murtha, to reporters, or to unnamed forces "who would reduce war crimes to mere partisan footballs." They seem to be in some parallel universe, where not only is Jack Murtha anti-Marine but John Kline, the Republican hawk retired-Marine-colonel-turned-Congressman, simply doesn't exist. If the military's own investigation, as briefed to Congress, didn't support Murtha's remarks, isn't it obvious that Kline, or one of the other Republicans who was briefed, might have said so?
And the accused Marines' lawyers' attempts to make the killings of civilians appear justified, or at least inadvertent, are going to run headlong into that Marine Corps press release claiming that the civilians were killed by a bomb. Just where did that story come from, if not from the Marines involved? And just precisely what is the relationship between the story they're telling now and the story they told immediately after action, and then to the first two investigations?
The two key-phrases in the warbloggers' campaign to shoot the bearers of bad tidings are "rush to judgment" and "presumption of innocence." This confuses principles of legal procedure with principles of factual interpretation. As far as their trial by court-martial is concerned, of course the accused Marines are entitled to the presumption of innocence, and it would be wrong for the judges in those cases to prejudge the evidence. But here in the real world, we make judgments every day on evidence that hasn't been presented to a court.
Who killed Nicole Simpson? A jury acquitted her husband. That means he can't be criminally punished. But it doesn't make him innocent in fact.
At the only trial Bill Clinton ever faced — his impeachment trial before the Senate — he was acquitted. That doesn't make the blue dress disappear.
Footnote
Murtha is excoriated for saying that the Marines involved killed "in cold blood." I wouldn't have used the phrase, because of its ambiguity. It can mean "coolly and calmly, with premeditation," or it can mean simply "not in confusion or panic."
In the heat of battle, civilians or captives are sometimes killed in ways that are unjustified, but are explicable, and partly excusable, because they were quick reactions in settings where there was no time to think clearly. If the reports that most of the victims were killed by shots to the back of the head are true, that doesn't seem to have been the case at Haditha.
But the killings clearly weren't "cold-blooded" in the Mafia-hit-man sense of the term. And Murtha never said they were. Here's his complete quote:
Our troops overreacted because of the pressure on them, and they killed innocent civilians in cold blood.
The Marines were apparently physically and emotionally exhausted by extended service under high-stress conditions, and enraged by the killing of one of their comrades.
Those now either defending the indefensible or pretending that it didn't happen have no such excuse.
The better analogy, and one proving the dishonesty of the proffered analogy, is . . .
"You and I are in a crowded room. Suddenly I throw a punch and hit you quite squarely in the jaw. You go down, then arise quickly, but I have already run out into another room. Though quite shaken, you immediately enter a room that I did not flee to, and that you have no real evidence to indicate that I fled to, and start hitting every person in sight, including all the women, despite the fact that you know you were hit by a man."
Posted by: Advocate for God at June 13, 2006 06:45 AMThere is a reason why Insty doesn't have comments.
Posted by: mickslam at June 13, 2006 03:55 PMI haven't been following closely the bloggy response to Haditha, but my own response is thus:
We don't know what the facts are yet, and we won't until the DoD investigation is complete. "Facts" reported in the media regarding Iraq are quite often not factual, and the American media has been unable or unwilling to prevent itself from being used as propaganda tools by our enemies in Iraq; therefore anything appearing in the media is of suspect factual status. Reports in the NYT, etc., about Iraq have much truthiness to them.
If indeed the reports that Marines killed civilans in cold blood, they should be punished, severely, and the punishment should be publicised in Iraq.
Lastly, the fact that Americans, even Americans in uniform, can commit crimes, and can successfully cover up those crimes, does not reflect on the moral status of the United States, or of the military mission in which we are engaged in Iraq. If the military heirarchy was complicit in covering up the crimes, or the government refused to carry out punishment upon determining to some appropriate legal standard that a crime did in fact occur, *that* would be a reflection on the morality of the government, the military, and/or the war in Iraq.
SO far, most lefty commentators on Haditha seem to assume that the existence of a small number of criminals in the Marines *does* reflect on the morality of the U.S. or the Marines or the War in Iraq. They're so wrong as to not be worth taking seriously. Those commentators also seem to assume that the responsible parties will not be punished even if there is legally convincing evidence of their crimes. That's also so wrong as to be not worth taking seriously.
Posted by: Anthony at June 15, 2006 04:50 PMAnthony: "S[o] far, most lefty commentators on Haditha seem to assume that the existence of a small number of criminals in the Marines *does* reflect on the morality of the U.S. or the Marines or the War in Iraq."
This is typical of the mendacity of many "Righties" who ignore the facts and continue to make up allegations against the "Left" in order to divert attention from the incompetencies, corruption, and immorality of the Bush administration.
People on the left have said that the cover up by people in the chain of command reflects on the morality of the military command and the administration and that the failure of the Bush administration to take actions necessary to prevent or limit such incidents, by providing sufficient troops, training, psychological treatment, armament, and planning, rather than providing tax cuts for wealthy contributors, reflects on the morality of the Administration.
It is a bald-faced lie to state that any significant number of "lefties", much less "most", have ever said or implied that the actions of a few rogue soldiers should be imputed to the country as a whole.
This is yet another example of Righties using love of country and support of our troops in a as cover for and a diversion from the crimes and failings of the Bush administration.
It is a shameful to take patriotism and concern for the welfare of our troops hostage for the purpose of protecting the partisan political fortunes of the Bush administration and deflecting legitimate criticism of the administration's planning and conduct of the war.
You are, however, free to provide quotes and links to prove your point that "most lefty commentators [sic]" have stated that the mere actions of a few soldiers reflects on the morality of the country as a whole.
We won't hold our breath.
Posted by: Advocate for God at June 16, 2006 07:02 AMhttp://www.la-ringtones.com/mp3/ ringtones site. Best free samsung ringtones, Cingular ringtones and more, Ringtones for free. from website .
Posted by: funny ringtones at July 6, 2006 02:55 AMfunny ringtones
Posted by: rcpfrdk@yahoo.com at July 14, 2006 12:21 PMhttp://www.ringtones-dir.com/get/ ringtones site free. Best free samsung ringtones, Cingular ringtones and more, Ringtones for free. From website .
Posted by: ringtones free at September 14, 2006 01:09 AMhttp://www.ringtones-dir.com/get/ ringtones site free. ringtones site free, ringtones site, Free nokia ringtones here. From website .
Posted by: ringtones free at October 25, 2006 05:51 AMfunny ringtones
Posted by: dtcoc27@search.com at October 25, 2006 05:51 AMlhciodamt pwltrfkua ftsgyvm hiseoy haks ygfk gcdzyrshm
Posted by: yjofizcuk pgri at November 1, 2006 06:24 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: phen at November 2, 2006 03:15 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: phen at November 2, 2006 03:15 AMGood site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: bedding ocean colors at November 7, 2006 02:58 AMGood site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: bedding ocean colors at November 7, 2006 02:59 AMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: 7004 at November 7, 2006 04:16 AMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: 7004 at November 7, 2006 04:16 AMVery good site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: 123479171 at November 7, 2006 04:34 AMCool site. Thanks.
Cool site. Thanks.
Good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: antique art deco wedding rings at November 7, 2006 05:02 AMGood site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: antique art deco wedding rings at November 7, 2006 05:02 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: hand truck at November 7, 2006 05:52 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: hand truck at November 7, 2006 05:52 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: adjustable arch supports at November 7, 2006 06:04 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: adjustable arch supports at November 7, 2006 06:04 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: the costs of plastic surgery at November 7, 2006 06:51 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: the costs of plastic surgery at November 7, 2006 06:51 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: xirlink at November 7, 2006 08:32 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: xirlink at November 7, 2006 08:32 AMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: psg1 at November 7, 2006 09:36 AMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: psg1 at November 7, 2006 09:36 AMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: lodge at November 7, 2006 11:20 AMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: lodge at November 7, 2006 11:21 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: little caesars at November 7, 2006 12:26 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: thomasville at November 7, 2006 12:29 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: beautifeel at November 7, 2006 01:10 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: beautifeel at November 7, 2006 01:11 PMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: david clulow at November 7, 2006 02:20 PMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: table saws at November 7, 2006 03:09 PMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: table saws at November 7, 2006 03:11 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: posterflag at November 7, 2006 04:01 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: posterflag at November 7, 2006 04:02 PMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: kristi yamaguchi at November 7, 2006 05:55 PMNice site. Thank you!
Posted by: phoebe philo at November 7, 2006 06:43 PMNice site. Thank you!
Posted by: phoebe philo at November 7, 2006 06:43 PMCool site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: dell2650 at November 7, 2006 06:57 PMCool site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: holden rover at November 7, 2006 06:58 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: tent at November 7, 2006 09:50 PMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: stoves at November 7, 2006 11:03 PMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: stoves at November 7, 2006 11:03 PMVery good site. Thank you.
Posted by: cb ham antenna towers and mounts at November 7, 2006 11:33 PMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: dollhouse miniature books at November 8, 2006 01:26 AMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: dollhouse miniature books at November 8, 2006 01:26 AMNice site. Thank you!
Posted by: demarini 375 softball at November 8, 2006 02:02 AMNice site. Thank you!
Posted by: demarini 375 softball at November 8, 2006 02:02 AMNice site. Thank you!
Posted by: schoolgirls at November 8, 2006 02:31 AMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: cathedral set engagement rings at November 8, 2006 04:10 AMCool site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: jla at November 8, 2006 04:24 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: unwrapping at November 8, 2006 04:24 AMCool site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: jla at November 8, 2006 04:24 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: unwrapping at November 8, 2006 04:24 AMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: compaq presario 1925 battery at November 8, 2006 05:32 AMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: compaq presario 1925 battery at November 8, 2006 05:32 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: supertexttwist at November 8, 2006 05:57 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: supertexttwist at November 8, 2006 05:57 AMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: cue dragon pool at November 8, 2006 06:19 AMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: cue dragon pool at November 8, 2006 06:19 AMNice site. Thank you.
Posted by: shopko at November 8, 2006 07:36 AMNice site. Thank you.
Posted by: shopko at November 8, 2006 07:36 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: 9000dn at November 8, 2006 08:00 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: 9000dn at November 8, 2006 08:01 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: katha diddel at November 8, 2006 08:55 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: katha diddel at November 8, 2006 08:55 AMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: used accounting books at November 8, 2006 10:38 AMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: used accounting books at November 8, 2006 10:38 AMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: hyperflight at November 8, 2006 11:19 AMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: hyperflight at November 8, 2006 11:19 AMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: billiard golf game at November 8, 2006 11:39 AMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: billiard golf game at November 8, 2006 11:40 AMNice site. Thank you.
Posted by: king size duvet cover at November 8, 2006 06:00 PMNice site. Thank you.
Posted by: king size duvet cover at November 8, 2006 06:00 PMVery good site. Thank you.
Posted by: cannon digital cammera telephoto lense at November 8, 2006 06:40 PMVery good site. Thank you.
Posted by: cannon digital cammera telephoto lense at November 8, 2006 06:40 PMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: sculpture at November 8, 2006 06:51 PMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: lotion at November 8, 2006 07:18 PMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: lotion at November 8, 2006 07:18 PMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: milliner at November 8, 2006 07:22 PMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: flask cigarette case at November 8, 2006 07:40 PMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: crack puzzle bobble at November 8, 2006 08:18 PMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: hyperflight at November 8, 2006 08:30 PMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: islamorada fl real estate at November 8, 2006 10:47 PMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: islamorada fl real estate at November 8, 2006 10:48 PMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: down comforter at November 10, 2006 12:44 PMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: down comforter at November 10, 2006 12:44 PMNice site. Thanks.
Posted by: black decker 18v cordless drill at November 10, 2006 02:02 PMNice site. Thanks.
Posted by: black decker 18v cordless drill at November 10, 2006 02:03 PMVery good site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: olympus digtal at November 10, 2006 02:50 PMVery good site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: olympus digtal at November 10, 2006 02:50 PMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: house of colors at November 11, 2006 04:28 PMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: house of colors at November 11, 2006 04:29 PMVery good site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: paradise island bahamas atlantis at November 11, 2006 05:39 PMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: cpi at November 11, 2006 06:27 PMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: thomas and thomas at November 12, 2006 08:00 AMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: thomas and thomas at November 12, 2006 08:00 AMCool site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: butterfly fleece fabric at November 12, 2006 09:10 AMCool site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: butterfly fleece fabric at November 12, 2006 09:11 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: overstocks at November 12, 2006 09:12 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: overstocks at November 12, 2006 09:12 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: prepaid trac phone card moldova at November 12, 2006 09:25 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: prepaid trac phone card moldova at November 12, 2006 09:26 AMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: polykrates at November 12, 2006 10:13 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: two busy moms at November 12, 2006 10:24 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: two busy moms at November 12, 2006 10:24 AMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: batterijen at November 12, 2006 12:15 PMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: wooden floors at November 12, 2006 12:18 PMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: wooden floors at November 12, 2006 12:19 PMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: captive at November 12, 2006 12:21 PMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: hk33 at November 12, 2006 12:26 PMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: hk33 at November 12, 2006 12:26 PMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: coil at November 12, 2006 12:51 PMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: armstrong faux tin ceiling tiles at November 12, 2006 01:01 PMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: armstrong faux tin ceiling tiles at November 12, 2006 01:01 PMVery good site. Thanks.
Posted by: bitty baby crib for doll at November 12, 2006 01:21 PMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: jennifer hawkins at November 12, 2006 01:37 PMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: jennifer hawkins at November 12, 2006 01:37 PMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: all star cruise at November 12, 2006 02:05 PMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: all star cruise at November 12, 2006 02:06 PMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: mix at November 12, 2006 02:32 PMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: herrendüfte at November 12, 2006 02:33 PMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: eau torride at November 12, 2006 04:44 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: powerwashing at November 12, 2006 07:53 PMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: foreign trades at November 12, 2006 08:04 PMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: canon powershot a100 download at November 12, 2006 08:33 PMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: ge cordless phones at November 12, 2006 08:42 PMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: bass night fishing lures at November 12, 2006 09:23 PMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: bass night fishing lures at November 12, 2006 09:24 PMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: bead charm italian at November 12, 2006 09:34 PMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: block of the month at November 12, 2006 09:35 PMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: block of the month at November 12, 2006 09:35 PMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: 57cm at November 12, 2006 10:36 PMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: playmobil en solde at November 13, 2006 05:47 AMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: kingspan at November 13, 2006 06:12 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: printer at November 13, 2006 06:27 AMNice site. Thanks.
Posted by: dc martens 1b61 chukka boots at November 13, 2006 06:32 AMNice site. Thanks.
Posted by: dc martens 1b61 chukka boots at November 13, 2006 06:33 AMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: locomotive air filter at November 13, 2006 07:45 AMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: gifgas at November 13, 2006 07:56 AMNice site. Thanks!
Posted by: gifgas at November 13, 2006 07:57 AMCool site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: mexican housekeeper at November 13, 2006 08:29 AMCool site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: mexican housekeeper at November 13, 2006 08:29 AMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: sanyo receiver at November 13, 2006 08:34 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: hot tuna at November 13, 2006 08:55 AMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: crocheted at November 13, 2006 08:56 AMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: crocheted at November 13, 2006 08:57 AMVery good site. Thank you!
Posted by: madison marie born at st john hospital at November 13, 2006 09:30 AMVery good site. Thank you!
Posted by: madison marie born at st john hospital at November 13, 2006 09:31 AMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: tube steps at November 13, 2006 09:39 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: how to program a sony rm v302 universal remote control at November 13, 2006 10:12 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: how to program a sony rm v302 universal remote control at November 13, 2006 10:13 AMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: zelfportretten at November 13, 2006 11:09 AMVery good site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: zelfportretten at November 13, 2006 11:09 AMVery good site. Thank you!
Posted by: hot pants at November 13, 2006 11:28 AMVery good site. Thank you!
Posted by: hot pants at November 13, 2006 11:28 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: clothes drop box at November 13, 2006 11:37 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: clothes drop box at November 13, 2006 11:38 AMVery good site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: locking neck collar at November 13, 2006 11:45 AMVery good site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: locking neck collar at November 13, 2006 11:46 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: qcp 6035 at November 13, 2006 02:26 PMVery good site. Thank you!
Posted by: lupi at November 13, 2006 03:32 PMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: virvana at November 13, 2006 03:55 PMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: euroclean at November 13, 2006 08:41 PMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: euroclean at November 13, 2006 08:42 PMVery good site. Thanks.
Posted by: videokasetti at November 13, 2006 09:12 PMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: sony vaio intel pentium 4 630 30 ghz computer at November 13, 2006 09:25 PMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: süà sauer at November 13, 2006 09:41 PMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: süà sauer at November 13, 2006 09:41 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: e410 at November 13, 2006 09:49 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: metal kitchen trash can at November 13, 2006 11:17 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: metal kitchen trash can at November 13, 2006 11:18 PMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: granite hot plate at November 13, 2006 11:27 PMCool site. Thank you!
Posted by: granite hot plate at November 13, 2006 11:27 PMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: sweatpants at November 14, 2006 01:35 AMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: sweatpants at November 14, 2006 01:36 AMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: lt1 camaro ss at November 14, 2006 03:28 AMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: lt1 camaro ss at November 14, 2006 03:28 AMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: church key can bottle opener at November 14, 2006 06:20 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: dell dimension 2300 driver at November 14, 2006 06:24 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: dell dimension 2300 driver at November 14, 2006 06:24 AMVery good site. Thanks.
Posted by: ofsted at November 14, 2006 06:41 AMVery good site. Thanks.
Posted by: ofsted at November 14, 2006 06:42 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: digiscoping at November 14, 2006 06:42 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: digiscoping at November 14, 2006 06:42 AMCool site. Thanks!
Posted by: digiscoping at November 14, 2006 06:43 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: copying dvd to vcr at November 14, 2006 08:17 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: audi key fob at November 14, 2006 08:42 AMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: belkin è´å°é f5d7010 at November 14, 2006 08:43 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: audi key fob at November 14, 2006 08:43 AMGood site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: belkin è´å°é f5d7010 at November 14, 2006 08:43 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: monopoly game board peices parker brothers milton bradley at November 14, 2006 10:47 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: monopoly game board peices parker brothers milton bradley at November 14, 2006 10:48 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: map of apartment building at November 14, 2006 11:08 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: map of apartment building at November 14, 2006 11:09 AMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: tonjon at November 14, 2006 11:20 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: lowest advertised price for 2006 isuzu ascender at November 14, 2006 11:44 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: lowest advertised price for 2006 isuzu ascender at November 14, 2006 11:44 AMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: allana slater at November 14, 2006 12:55 PMVery good site. Thanks!
Posted by: allana slater at November 14, 2006 12:55 PMGood site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: alphabet book on africa at November 14, 2006 02:20 PMGood site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: alphabet book on africa at November 14, 2006 02:20 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: encyclopedias at November 14, 2006 02:43 PMNice site. Thanks.
Posted by: callaway warbird golf balls at November 14, 2006 03:51 PMNice site. Thanks.
Posted by: callaway warbird golf balls at November 14, 2006 03:51 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: mcb at November 14, 2006 04:33 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: mcb at November 14, 2006 04:34 PMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: st catherines at November 14, 2006 04:54 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: mogami at November 14, 2006 04:56 PMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: mogami at November 14, 2006 04:57 PMGood site. Thank you.
Posted by: wicked at November 14, 2006 05:07 PMGood site. Thank you.
Posted by: wicked at November 14, 2006 05:08 PMVery good site. Thank you.
Posted by: towels at November 14, 2006 05:19 PMVery good site. Thank you.
Posted by: towels at November 14, 2006 05:20 PMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: collectible at November 14, 2006 05:56 PMNice site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: collectible at November 14, 2006 05:56 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: a ship flying the yellow jack flag have on board at November 14, 2006 06:02 PMCool site. Thank you.
Posted by: a ship flying the yellow jack flag have on board at November 14, 2006 06:02 PMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: burning monkey puzzle lab at November 14, 2006 06:53 PMGood site. Thank you!
Posted by: burning monkey puzzle lab at November 14, 2006 06:54 PMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: gift shop at November 14, 2006 09:56 PMVery good site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: gift shop at November 14, 2006 09:56 PMCool site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: jake jacobs spyder at November 14, 2006 10:14 PMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: home security camera kit at November 14, 2006 10:22 PMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: speedway motors at November 15, 2006 12:43 AMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: myfreecheck at November 15, 2006 12:45 AMCool site. Thanks.
Posted by: nv ds15eg at November 15, 2006 12:59 AMCool site. Thanks.
Posted by: nv ds15eg at November 15, 2006 12:59 AMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: cowgirl store purse bag at November 15, 2006 01:12 AMGood site. Thanks.
Posted by: cowgirl store purse bag at November 15, 2006 01:13 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: classic spiderman comics at November 15, 2006 01:32 AMGood site. Thanks!
Posted by: classic spiderman comics at November 15, 2006 01:33 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: diesels at November 15, 2006 01:38 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: diesels at November 15, 2006 01:38 AMGood site. Thank you.
Posted by: plotter designjet 750c plus at November 15, 2006 01:59 AMNice site. Thanks:-)
Posted by: ball pit at November 15, 2006 02:21 AMCool site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: flight 001 at November 15, 2006 02:29 AMGood site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: elves at November 15, 2006 03:01 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: myrtle beach condo golf vacation resort at November 15, 2006 03:47 AMVery good site. Thank you.
Good site. Thank you.
Good site. Thank you.
Nice site. Thank you!
Nice site. Thank you!
Very good site. Thank you.
Cool site. Thanks!
Cool site. Thanks:-)
Good site. Thank you!
Good site. Thank you!
Very good site. Thank you:-)
Cool site. Thank you!
Cool site. Thank you!
Very good site. Thanks!!!
Very good site. Thanks!!!
Good site. Thanks!
Good site. Thanks!
Very good site. Thanks.
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Good site. Thank you!!!
Nice site. Thank you!!!
Nice site. Thank you!!!
Cool site. Thanks.
Cool site. Thanks.
Very good site. Thanks.
Very good site. Thanks.
Cool site. Thanks!
Very good site. Thank you!
Good site. Thank you.
Good site. Thank you.
Cool site. Thanks.
Cool site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thank you!!!
Very good site. Thank you!!!
Cool site. Thank you!!!
Very good site. Thanks!!!
Good site. Thank you!!!
Very good site. Thanks!!!
Very good site. Thanks!!!
Cool site. Thanks.
Cool site. Thank you!
Cool site. Thank you!
Good site. Thanks!!!
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Nice site. Thanks!!!
Good site. Thanks!
Good site. Thanks!
Very good site. Thanks!
Very good site. Thanks!
Nice site. Thank you.
Nice site. Thank you.
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thanks:-)
Very good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: 2007[/URL] at December 2, 2006 02:54 AMVery good site. Thank you:-)
Posted by: 2007[/URL] at December 2, 2006 02:55 AMjyqmh nioc gyinjt bmcanh zfbvcery hwebxk mhai
Posted by: djfthr depghfaz at December 2, 2006 05:00 AMNice site. Thank you!
Nice site. Thank you!
Very good site. Thanks.
Very good site. Thanks.
Good site. Thank you!
Good site. Thank you!
Nice site. Thanks.
Good site. Thanks:-)
Cool site. Thanks:-)
Cool site. Thanks:-)
ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77p
Posted by: ringtones download at December 3, 2006 04:33 AMygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77 ygwas4898e7ae77p
Posted by: ringtones download at December 3, 2006 06:13 AMljfcseob vdbwqmg gawpbu fywi dvunk wdpasn tlsuyrb
Posted by: wdyfxz yzbgcuvlp at December 3, 2006 09:08 AMNice site. Thank you!!!
Posted by: hayes disk brakes at December 4, 2006 06:10 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: brakes caliper high performance at December 4, 2006 08:19 AMNice site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: brakes caliper high performance at December 4, 2006 08:19 AMGood site. Thanks!!!
Posted by: turin brakes at December 4, 2006 08:58 AMNice site. Thank you!
Very nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Lzolfojo at December 8, 2006 06:03 AMVery nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Lzolfojo at December 8, 2006 06:04 AMNzrvkjdp
volvo
Nzrvkjdp
It is very creative and includes a wealth of information.
Posted by: Pierre at December 8, 2006 09:55 PMVery nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Thomas at December 8, 2006 10:47 PMI am glad to find this site.
Posted by: William at December 10, 2006 04:14 AMNice site it's very interesting site! your site is fantastic.
Posted by: Jack at December 10, 2006 04:27 AMGreat site! Regards: Thanks for the good info Way I'll be back very soon to see any update.
Posted by: Victor at December 10, 2006 04:38 AMVery nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Danila at December 11, 2006 04:34 AMFabulous Website! It is very creative and includes a wealth of information.
Posted by: Patrick at December 11, 2006 04:45 AMGreat site! Regards: Thanks for the good info Way I'll be back very soon to see any update.
Posted by: Nicolas at December 11, 2006 04:49 AMVery nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Gerard at December 11, 2006 04:58 AMThis site rule the world! Keep fighting
Posted by: John at December 12, 2006 11:12 AMFabulous Website! It is very creative and includes a wealth of information.
Posted by: John at December 12, 2006 11:33 AMGreat site! Regards: Thanks for the good info Way I'll be back very soon to see any update.
Posted by: Hans at December 12, 2006 11:41 AMIt is very creative and includes a wealth of information.
Posted by: Christian at December 12, 2006 11:45 AMVery nice site. Thanks for your hard work in this site. I m glad I stopped by and will again many times.
Posted by: Peter at December 13, 2006 12:48 AMVery interesting site ! Good work ! Nongratulations :)
Posted by: Edward at December 13, 2006 01:12 AMVery nice site. Thanks for your hard work in this site. I m glad I stopped by and will again many times.
Posted by: Bryan at December 13, 2006 01:14 AMHello all! Very nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Henry at December 13, 2006 01:53 AMHello all! Very nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Robert at December 13, 2006 02:04 AMThis site rule the world! Keep fighting
Posted by: Dima at December 13, 2006 02:12 AMGreat page! I think it's cool! When is the next update?
Posted by: Michel at December 13, 2006 02:53 AMVery interesting site ! Good work ! Nongratulations :)
Posted by: Richard at December 13, 2006 04:40 AMI am glad to find this site.
Posted by: Linda at December 13, 2006 04:47 AMit is very nice to be on this site pls.your effort is nice keep it moving.
Posted by: Harry at December 13, 2006 04:50 AMI am glad to find this site.
Posted by: Gaston at December 13, 2006 06:25 AMHi! Very nice and beautifull place! Keep it!
Posted by: Hans at December 13, 2006 06:58 AMYour site is very very cool !! I love it :) Respect !
Posted by: Bernard at December 13, 2006 07:35 AMHello all! Very nice site and very informativity!
Posted by: Jacque at December 13, 2006 07:58 AMIt is very creative and includes a wealth of information.
Posted by: Alain at December 13, 2006 09:05 AMVery interesting site ! Good work ! Nongratulations :)
Posted by: Gaultier at December 13, 2006 09:09 AMNice site it's very interesting site! your site is fantastic.
Posted by: John at December 13, 2006 09:15 AMVery nice site. Thanks for your hard work in this site. I m glad I stopped by and will again many times.
Posted by: John at December 13, 2006 09:51 AMVery nice site. Thanks for your hard work in this site. I m glad I stopped by and will again many times.
Posted by: Paul at December 18, 2006 07:45 AMVery interesting site ! Good work ! Nongratulations :)
Posted by: Ales at December 18, 2006 08:08 AMThanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)