May 08, 2006

 Desperation

Next time you read that the military-manpower situation is under control, consider this.

No, signing up an autistic 18-year-old who never speaks unless spoken to as a cavalry scout isn't as serious operationally as promoting 97% of all eligible captains to major. But as a sign of complete desperation, it's pretty extreme.

Comments

Signing up an autistic kid isn't necessarily a sign of desperation. Recruiters are happy to get their numbers however they can, reagardless of the likelihood that the recruit will succeed in the military. If the kid gets through basic training & AIT without being washed out, that will be a sign of desperation. Unless standards have dropped way down from when I went through basic, that probably won't happen.

Posted by: Tony Dismukes at May 9, 2006 07:11 AM

jared seems to me like the ideal weapon: i'm fairly sure autism stands up as diminished capacity in court so... even if we DID support some sort of international court of justice, or if we (gasp) tried warcrimes here, or even if we went out on a limb to consider the massacre of workers, mothers, and children wandering around their cities, their countries, going about their daily lives a crime, well, then, an autistic army pretty much absolves american forces of any wrongdoing. this isn't desperation, it's sheer tactical genius.

actually, as i reread, i feel a little guilty about my caustic sarcasm... for the record, i find this jared's enlistment both abusive and appaling. and i think his parents have real ground to pull their son's name from the roster, claiming that their 18-year old kid has the developmental capacity of someone several years younger, someone who is NOT yet (mentally) an adult, nor in sufficient control of his faculties so as to consider the consequences of his very adult actions. but the question remains, whether he gets through basic or not (will they make exceptions since he's in and we "need" men on the front lines?), what the ASS are these recruiters thinking?!?!? i can't imagine he'd make a reliable soldier with the attention span of a pre-teen and a propensity to push buttons at will... is it really just a numbers game?

i'm so disillusioned.

Posted by: alex at May 9, 2006 08:55 AM

It really IS a numbers game.

Recruiters aren't punished when their recruits wash out of basic, or get shot on the battlefield, or frag their officers, so they shove all the bodies they can into the machine, fit or no.

It's all a matter of what's rewarded and what's punished.

Failing to meet quota is punished, so that's what they do... meet quota... no matter what the cost.

Posted by: Vaxalon at May 9, 2006 09:55 AM

What Tony said. Recruiters will sign up any warm body, and I was in basic training with a few of guys who you would barely trust with a toothrbrush, let alone an M-16. None of them, however, successfully completed basic.

Posted by: trotsky at May 10, 2006 04:58 PM
Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?


recipes

eXTReMe Tracker