April 02, 2006
Employer sanctions: enforcement is everything
A reader points out that my earlier charge that Republican anti-immigration proposals exclude employer sanctions is overbroad. The Sensenbrenner bill provides for the creation of a data-base of those eligible to work, with stiff fines for employers who fail to check before hiring. The Frist bill also has employer-sanctions provisions, though bizarrely it "grandfathers" existing employment relationships. (Why not go the whole way, then, and grandfather the aliens holding those jobs? Otherwise, you make them captives of their current employers, and thus even more exploitable than they are now.)
But in either version the key question remains enforcement. How secure will the system be? How hard or easy will it be to beat it by pretending to be someone on the list? Can employers get away with pretending to believe that job applicants are who they pretend to be, as they get away now with pretending to be fooled by counterfeit green cards? And why shouldn't we expect the same companies who have secured from BushCo lax enforcement of the environmental and workplace-safety laws to secure lax enforcement of employer sanctions from any Republican successor?
In any case the provisions in the Sensenbrenner and Frist bills to stiffen sanctions against the illegal aliens themselves would make enforcement of their employer-sanctions provisions virtually impossible.
Effective enforcement of employer sanctions needs the cooperation of the illegal aliens themselves as complainants and witnesses. Stiffening sanctions against them, as the Republican bills do, deters them from complaining or testifying, making them more attractive to employers. (It also makes them much more attractive as crime victims by increasing their fear of the authorities. This will increase the actual crime rate while reducing the apparent crime rate, which is based mostly on victim complaints.) Felonizing illegal entry, therefore, isn't just pointless, it's counterproductive, if the goal is to slow the influx across the southern border.
But if the goal is to exploit nativist fears without seriously inconveniencing employers too cheap to pay what citizens would demand to do their dirty work, making illegal immigration a felony makes perfect sense. No only does it sound tough, by frustrating enforcement of employer sanctions it actually helps guarantee that they ... keep ... coming, as Pete Wilson's successful re-election ads warned they would, thus maintaining illegal immigration as a live issue to be exploited in future elections.
Whatever level of immigration occurs, we should work as hard as possible to make sure that as much of it as possible is legal, because illegal immigration is a crime problem, a terrorism problem, and makes illegal immigrants and their children much worse off, and much worse neighbors, than they would otherwise be. So we should both expand legal immigration and toughen enforcement against illegal immigration and the employment of illegal immigrations, to squeeze down on the size of the illegal underclass.
Instead, we reach a bad compromise — excessively strict quotas plus lax enforcement — that gives us the worst of both worlds: fewer legal immigrants than the country could comfortably absorb and benefit from economically, and more illegal immigrants than it's healthy or safe for us to have around.
Fine points, especially how the compromise is likely to be terrible.
The real solution, a much smaller and less corrupt Mexican gov't with much greater economic chances there, is even more unlikely than the US gov't getting policy right.
Posted by: Tom Grey - Liberty Dad at April 4, 2006 04:56 AMYou believe that enforcement of the laws against hiring illegal immigrants will depend on the illegal immigrants who are hired turning in their employers and testifying against hiring them? I don’t get it. You’re mixing the violation of workplace laws that apply to everyone with laws against hiring illegals. Like almost everything around enforcement, you can make an argument that it interferes with some other goal. But the underlying assumption necessary for the problem of protecting illegal workers from workplace abuse is that there will continue to be the employment of illegal immigrants.
The idea that the amount of legal immigration that is greater than any other country in the world is too restrictive is as you put it, an opinion not a fact. Nothing but enforcement will stem people from coming here.
The way I understand it, the felony provision was actually kept in HR 4437 by the Democrats. Sensenbrenner was advised of problems with it and tried to remove it but Democrats voted 191 to 8 against reducing it to a misdemeanor. It has certainly been a major argument against the bill and I suppose they didn’t want to give it up.
Sensenbrenner also uses the already existing basic pilot program for employment verification purposed. It has been around for years but used only on a voluntary basis and the GAO expressed that despite some problems it holds promise.
Are you sure 40428 of this?!?
Posted by: Gezer Gamadi at October 3, 2006 03:28 PMmature enema sex stories old mature nasty
Posted by: Xeapoaitya at October 9, 2006 08:26 PMmature enema sex stories old mature nasty
Posted by: Xeapoaitya at October 9, 2006 08:27 PMmature enema sex stories old mature nasty
Posted by: Xeapoaitya at October 9, 2006 08:28 PMgfkcnfub
Posted by: Marquez Bustamante at October 31, 2006 08:58 PMawvexep
Posted by: Isaiah Kaiser at November 1, 2006 02:29 AMTV host Oprah Winfrey gives audience members $1,000 (£526) each to donate to a charitable cause...
Posted by: Darrion Feliciano at November 17, 2006 12:12 AMTV host Oprah Winfrey gives audience members $1,000 (£526) each to donate to a charitable cause...
Posted by: Darrion Feliciano at November 17, 2006 12:32 AMThe Rolling Stones cancel a gig in Hawaii and postpone other tour dates as Mick Jagger suffers throat troubles...
Posted by: Humberto Minton at November 22, 2006 06:03 AMPop trio Atomic Kitten will reform to play a concert in support of jailed Liverpool football fan Michael Shields...
Posted by: Cade Outlaw at November 22, 2006 12:25 PMColombia's vice president is "baffled" by Kate Moss's success following cocaine allegations...
Posted by: Edward Salley at November 23, 2006 02:13 PMVeteran actor William Franklyn, known for voicing the 1960s Schweppes TV adverts, dies aged 81...
Posted by: Daquan Lindsay at November 25, 2006 03:19 AMJonathan Ross is dubbed "risque" by Ofcom but not in breach of rules over an interview with David Cameron...
Posted by: Sam Kenney at November 25, 2006 03:50 PMBorat creator Sacha Baron Cohen reportedly signs a $42.5m (£22m) film deal starring his character Bruno...
Posted by: Clarence Wilkes at November 27, 2006 03:50 PMMadonna says she may adopt another child from abroad following her proposed adoption of a Malawian boy...
Posted by: Kade Ott at November 30, 2006 03:49 PMPioneering screenwriter Nigel Kneale, best known for the Quatermass TV serials and films, dies aged 84...
Posted by: Stefan Warner at December 4, 2006 06:44 AMThe judge who put coded messages in his Da Vinci Code plagiarism trial ruling has written another...
Posted by: Griffin Michel at December 4, 2006 07:26 PMClassical singer Russell Watson postpones his forthcoming UK tour after undergoing brain surgery...
Posted by: Braiden Dunbar at December 5, 2006 01:58 PMPioneering screenwriter Nigel Kneale, best known for the Quatermass TV serials and films, dies aged 84...
Posted by: Raymundo Weed at December 6, 2006 06:40 AMJonathan Ross is dubbed "risque" by Ofcom but not in breach of rules over an interview with David Cameron...
Posted by: Jairo Petersen at December 6, 2006 10:24 AMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Perry Mackey at December 6, 2006 10:34 AMBorat creator Sacha Baron Cohen reportedly signs a $42.5m (£22m) film deal starring his character Bruno...
Posted by: Brice Nicholas at December 6, 2006 11:05 AMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Jaylon Meehan at December 7, 2006 01:30 AMPioneering screenwriter Nigel Kneale, best known for the Quatermass TV serials and films, dies aged 84...
Posted by: Reuben Messenger at December 7, 2006 01:50 AMThe Red Hot Chili Peppers are leading the way at this years MTV Europe music awards with four nominations...
Posted by: Amari Forbes at December 7, 2006 02:53 AMThe Red Hot Chili Peppers are leading the way at this years MTV Europe music awards with four nominations...
Posted by: Richard Buchanan at December 11, 2006 02:27 AMMadonna says she may adopt another child from abroad following her proposed adoption of a Malawian boy...
Posted by: Nikolas Glaser at December 11, 2006 03:10 AMMadonna says she may adopt another child from abroad following her proposed adoption of a Malawian boy...
Posted by: Hugh Bourne at December 11, 2006 03:26 AMVeteran actor William Franklyn, known for voicing the 1960s Schweppes TV adverts, dies aged 81...
Posted by: Josh Riddle at December 11, 2006 03:55 AMTV host Oprah Winfrey gives audience members $1,000 (£526) each to donate to a charitable cause...
Posted by: Jeremy Lovejoy at December 11, 2006 04:42 AMThe judge who put coded messages in his Da Vinci Code plagiarism trial ruling has written another...
Posted by: Nicholas Bandy at December 11, 2006 06:00 AMThe judge who put coded messages in his Da Vinci Code plagiarism trial ruling has written another...
Posted by: Nicholas Bandy at December 11, 2006 06:01 AMRecord company EMI sign a deal with the estate of crooner Dean Martin to use the singer's likeness...
Posted by: Darius Free at December 11, 2006 08:05 PMRecord company EMI sign a deal with the estate of crooner Dean Martin to use the singer's likeness...
Posted by: Darius Free at December 11, 2006 08:06 PMLondon-born rapper Sway is to be honoured at the BET Hip-Hop awards in the US...
Posted by: Josue Breland at December 13, 2006 03:21 PMSinger George Michael lends the piano on which John Lennon wrote Imagine to an anti-war exhibition...
Posted by: Camron Sandberg at December 13, 2006 05:40 PMSinger George Michael lends the piano on which John Lennon wrote Imagine to an anti-war exhibition...
Posted by: Camron Sandberg at December 13, 2006 05:41 PMClassical singer Russell Watson postpones his forthcoming UK tour after undergoing brain surgery...
Posted by: Nolan Allan at December 13, 2006 06:16 PMThe judge who put coded messages in his Da Vinci Code plagiarism trial ruling has written another...
Posted by: Elmer Lenz at December 13, 2006 06:43 PMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Branden Ahrens at December 15, 2006 03:35 PMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Branden Ahrens at December 15, 2006 03:39 PMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Markus Ferrer at December 15, 2006 06:48 PMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Roderick Newby at December 15, 2006 07:13 PMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Roderick Newby at December 15, 2006 07:15 PMJonathan Ross is dubbed "risque" by Ofcom but not in breach of rules over an interview with David Cameron...
Posted by: Julius Oreilly at December 17, 2006 01:46 AMPop trio Atomic Kitten will reform to play a concert in support of jailed Liverpool football fan Michael Shields...
Posted by: Kevon Hill at December 17, 2006 04:25 AMThe Rolling Stones postpone a show in the US to allow singer Sir Mick Jagger time to rest his voice...
Posted by: Roland Vines at December 17, 2006 05:56 AMThe Rolling Stones postpone a show in the US to allow singer Sir Mick Jagger time to rest his voice...
Posted by: Roland Vines at December 17, 2006 05:58 AMBorat creator Sacha Baron Cohen reportedly signs a $42.5m (£22m) film deal starring his character Bruno...
Posted by: Alexander Eggleston at December 17, 2006 12:28 PMJonathan Ross is dubbed "risque" by Ofcom but not in breach of rules over an interview with David Cameron...
Posted by: Eugene Irons at December 17, 2006 02:19 PMJonathan Ross is dubbed "risque" by Ofcom but not in breach of rules over an interview with David Cameron...
Posted by: Eugene Irons at December 17, 2006 02:24 PMRecord company EMI sign a deal with the estate of crooner Dean Martin to use the singer's likeness...
Posted by: Colby Woodworth at December 17, 2006 07:17 PMRecord company EMI sign a deal with the estate of crooner Dean Martin to use the singer's likeness...
Posted by: Colby Woodworth at December 17, 2006 07:22 PMA musical about the witches from The Wizard of Oz breaks West End box office records, its producers say...
Posted by: Marquise Washington at December 18, 2006 12:44 AMA musical about the witches from The Wizard of Oz breaks West End box office records, its producers say...
Posted by: Marquise Washington at December 18, 2006 01:01 AMThe Red Hot Chili Peppers are leading the way at this years MTV Europe music awards with four nominations...
Posted by: Kent Duffy at December 18, 2006 02:50 AMLondon-born rapper Sway is to be honoured at the BET Hip-Hop awards in the US...
Posted by: Abel Kennedy at December 18, 2006 04:45 AMThe first stage of a £150m investment in regional museums is praised for boosting visitor numbers...
Posted by: Shannon Atherton at December 18, 2006 05:48 AMA musical about the witches from The Wizard of Oz breaks West End box office records, its producers say...
Posted by: Ahmad Carrico at December 18, 2006 07:04 AMThe first stage of a £150m investment in regional museums is praised for boosting visitor numbers...
Posted by: Braiden Mcclary at December 18, 2006 07:23 AMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Mitchel Finnegan at December 18, 2006 07:50 AMMicrosoft and Peter Jackson postpone the making of a film based on the Halo video game after backers pull out...
Posted by: Mitchel Finnegan at December 18, 2006 07:53 AMLondon-born rapper Sway is to be honoured at the BET Hip-Hop awards in the US...
Posted by: Don Patton at December 18, 2006 08:16 AMColombia's vice president is "baffled" by Kate Moss's success following cocaine allegations...
Posted by: Vincent Maki at December 18, 2006 08:41 AMJonathan Ross is dubbed "risque" by Ofcom but not in breach of rules over an interview with David Cameron...
Posted by: Carlos Hubbard at December 27, 2006 07:35 AMRecord company EMI sign a deal with the estate of crooner Dean Martin to use the singer's likeness...
Posted by: Blaise Langston at December 27, 2006 10:11 AMRecord company EMI sign a deal with the estate of crooner Dean Martin to use the singer's likeness...
Posted by: Gannon Luce at December 27, 2006 11:05 AMA musical about the witches from The Wizard of Oz breaks West End box office records, its producers say...
Posted by: James Littlefield at December 27, 2006 01:51 PMSocial networking site MySpace is to block users from uploading copyrighted music to its pages...
Posted by: Caden Jefferies at December 27, 2006 02:17 PMWilliam Styron, whose Holocaust novel Sophie's Choice became a film and an opera, has died, aged 81...
Posted by: Garrison Sauer at December 27, 2006 02:42 PMThe first stage of a £150m investment in regional museums is praised for boosting visitor numbers...
Posted by: Romeo Perry at December 27, 2006 03:11 PMColombia's vice president is "baffled" by Kate Moss's success following cocaine allegations...
Posted by: Eugene Gaskin at December 27, 2006 04:55 PMThanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
