The Reality-Based Community

Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.

  • Home
  • About
  • Cannabis Science & Policy Summit
  • MJ Legalization: The Book
  • BOTEC Analysis
You are here: Home / Elementary negotiation theory and health care legislation

Elementary negotiation theory and health care legislation

September 20, 2009 By Mark Kleiman @markarkleiman

1.  Health care legislation can avoid a filibuster and pass with 50 votes plus the Vice-President’s tie-breaker if it’s done via the budget reconciliation process.

2.  The Byrd Rule limits what can be done that way; the result would certainly be suboptimal compared to doing the same thing via ordinary legislation.  But that means 60 votes to break a filibuster.  That might be done with only Democratic votes if some Dems who plan to vote against final passage could be convinced that party loyalty ought to dominate their personal policy preferences or electoral calculations.  But that means giving every centrist-to-conservative Democratic Senator veto power.

3.  Basic negotiation theory starts with the question, “What happens if there isn’t a bargain?  How good or bad is that for each side?   In jargon, what is each side’s best alternative to a negotiated agreement (BATNA)?  The worse the BATNA, the stronger the need for a deal, and the weaker the bargaining position.

4.  Right now, the good guys want a bill and the bad guys don’t want a bill.  It’s hard to imagine any bill that’s better for Mitch McConnell than no bill.  So the obvious outcome of bargaining is no deal, or a very, very bad deal for the Democrats.

4.  So the obvious move for the good guys is to use the reconciliation process to make the BATNA better for Democrats, liberals, and the pro-health-reform interest groups better and – equally important – worse for conservatives, Republicans, and the anti-reform interest groups.  Once a bill passes under reconciliation that forbids some of the worst insurance abuses, heavily subsidizes health insurance for the poor and middle-income groups, raises taxes on the rich and on alcohol, and puts a cap on insurance-company executives’ pay, the balance of bargaining advantages reverses itself.  Now it’s the right that needs something else to pass.

5.   In this scenario, reconciliation isn’t a substitute for ordinary legislation but instead a prelude to negotiations about such legislation.  As Al Capone is supposed to have said, “You get more cooperation with a kind word and a gun than with a kind word alone.”

All this seems obvious to me, but all the journalism I see treats reconciliation and ordinary legislation as alternatives, rather than complements.

Can anyone explain this to me?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Popular Posts of the Week

  • There’s ordinary genius. Then there’s this video
  • Advice to Alex M
  • The libertine’s one-way ticket from Prague
  • The Secret Dubbing of Audrey Hepburn in My Fair Lady
  • Witnessing Violence and Death: What Happens to People and How Can They Be Helped?

Blogroll

  • Balloon Juice
  • The Belgravia Dispatch
  • Brad DeLong
  • Cop in the ‘hood
  • Crooked Timber
  • Crooks and Liars
  • Echidne of the Snakes
  • Firedoglake
  • A Fistful of Euros
  • Healthinsurance.org Blog
  • Horizons
  • How Appealing
  • The Incidental Economist
  • Informed Comment — Juan Cole
  • Jonathan Bernstein
  • Kevin Drum
  • Marginal Revolution – Tyler Cowen
  • Marijuana Monitor
  • The Moderate Voice
  • Obsidian Wings
  • Patheos
  • Philosoraptor
  • Plato o Plomo – Alejandro Hope
  • Political Animal
  • Politics Upside Down
  • Progressive Blog Digest
  • Progressive Blue
  • Slacktivist
  • Snopes
  • Strange Doctrines
  • Ta-Nehisi Coates
  • The Volokh Conspiracy (Washington Post)
  • Vox Pop

Recent Posts

  • “I take it the answer is: ‘No comment’?”
  • There’s ordinary genius. Then there’s this video
  • The libertine’s one-way ticket from Prague
  • Recommended reading on Brexit and the Future of the EU
  • Cannabis News Round-Up

Archives

Topic Areas

Copyright © 2017 The Reality-Based Community  •  Designed & Developed by ReadyMadeWeb LLC