April 10th, 2009

… is the young hero of a series of fantasy novels by Rick Riordan. A friend just gave me the first, The Lightening Thief.

Even to explain the premise would be a spoiler, but it’s both unexpected and profound. The stories are very nicely written. The obvious comparison is the Harry Potter series; these books are shorter, without the wealth of Dickensian characters, but correspondingly more tightly plotted. Overall, I’d say the literary level is about the same, and I rate Rowling high, though not as high as Ursula LeGuin, whose Earthsea stories are unmatched.

And, as it happened, Moe’s in Berkeley turned out to have a hardcover copy of Tolkien’s superb Smith of Wootton Major, an astonishingly fine performance and with nary a hobbit in sight.

Update A reader points to a newly published Tolkein volume containing not only Smith of Wootton Major, but Farmer Giles of Ham, Leaf by Niggle, The Adventures of Tom Bombadil, and the wonderful and underappreciated Roverrandom.

Comments are closed.