The Reality-Based Community

Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.

  • Home
  • About
  • Cannabis Science & Policy Summit
  • MJ Legalization: The Book
  • BOTEC Analysis
You are here: Home / Are lifejackets a waste of money?

Are lifejackets a waste of money?

January 16, 2009 By James Wimberley

The Economist said so:

In the history of aviation the number of wide-bodied aircraft that have made successful landings on water is zero. (September 2006)….

The life jackets … have little purpose other than to make passengers feel better. (2005)

Wikipedia supplies a long list of ditchings by narrow-bodied planes, with gratifyingly high survival rates, so the life jackets do make a difference. But just suppose yesterday’s brilliant airliner ditching in the Hudson was an outlier, and there really had been no precedents. Would that mean that life jackets fail a rational cost-benefit analysis (CBA)?

lifejacket.gif

Like many other laymen, I’m uneasy about CBA when it’s applied to safety across a broad sweep, maximising “quality adjusted life years” regardless of context. It strips out our prior contractual relationships, legitimate and unreasonable expectations, agency and dependence, and rational or imaginary anxieties. But within a narrow field like aviation safety it should generate a fair list of priorities.

Without proper data, I surmise that since aircraft lifejackets save few lives but don’t cost much, they would go fairly well down a blank-sheet CBA list of safety measures. There are several things which commercial aviation could do and doesn’t that would probably come higher up:

* defibrillators on all larger planes

* training of one member of each cabin crew to paramedic standard

* infirmaries and low-impact exercise rooms on superjumbos

* backwards-facing seats as on military transport aircraft

* no sales of hard liquor (I stop there because I usually drink wine on flights).

Even if lifejackets come low down, that doesn’t mean they should be dropped. The Economist seems to think it unimportant to “make passengers feel better”. One in ten of us is seriously anxious about flying, and anxiety can turn to panic, so reassurance is vital. The flight jacket demonstration ritual does just that, adding a little indoctrination for everybody into the aviator’s attitude to danger: keep calm and always do something however small the chance of it working. Thinking about putting on a lifejacket makes the passenger into an agent fighting for life, not just a potential victim of tragedy. “Do not go gentle into that good night.“

The danger of such rituals is that they can stop you thinking about about better plans. That’s where cold-blooded CBA becomes useful.

Admiring congratulations to Captain Sullenberger and his 155 passengers.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Policy Analysis

Popular Posts of the Week

  • There’s ordinary genius. Then there’s this video
  • Cannabis News Round-Up
  • The libertine’s one-way ticket from Prague
  • Advice to Alex M
  • Witnessing Violence and Death: What Happens to People and How Can They Be Helped?

Blogroll

  • Balloon Juice
  • The Belgravia Dispatch
  • Brad DeLong
  • Cop in the ‘hood
  • Crooked Timber
  • Crooks and Liars
  • Echidne of the Snakes
  • Firedoglake
  • A Fistful of Euros
  • Healthinsurance.org Blog
  • Horizons
  • How Appealing
  • The Incidental Economist
  • Informed Comment — Juan Cole
  • Jonathan Bernstein
  • Kevin Drum
  • Marginal Revolution – Tyler Cowen
  • Marijuana Monitor
  • The Moderate Voice
  • Obsidian Wings
  • Patheos
  • Philosoraptor
  • Plato o Plomo – Alejandro Hope
  • Political Animal
  • Politics Upside Down
  • Progressive Blog Digest
  • Progressive Blue
  • Slacktivist
  • Snopes
  • Strange Doctrines
  • Ta-Nehisi Coates
  • The Volokh Conspiracy (Washington Post)
  • Vox Pop

Recent Posts

  • “I take it the answer is: ‘No comment’?”
  • There’s ordinary genius. Then there’s this video
  • The libertine’s one-way ticket from Prague
  • Recommended reading on Brexit and the Future of the EU
  • Cannabis News Round-Up

Archives

Topic Areas

Copyright © 2017 The Reality-Based Community  •  Designed & Developed by ReadyMadeWeb LLC