(Horace: behind the horseman rides black care)
French and international human rights groups filed torture charges yesterday in Paris against Donald Rumsfeld while he was giving a talk.
Is this a strategy? I hope so, because it’s a good one:
1. Prepare charges secretly against suspected torture perps for as many jurisdictions as possible.
2. Wait till the perps travel, then ambush them with charges.
- Media event overshadowing anything else about the trip; the perp scuttles away just in case; there’s no arrest.
- The charges stay on file, are investigated, and arrest warrants may be issued;
- Return trips become much riskier;
- Other perps (Tenet, Goss, Gonzales, Cambone, Miller, Addington and Yoo under the Nuremberg precedent, and above all Cheney and Bush) will have to worry about every foreign trip after they retire and pay for criminal defence lawyers all their lives;
- Eventually the spider’s web of torture charges will make travel too risky for the perps over much of the globe.
There’s only an outside chance of actual foreign torture trials of US citizens. Few foreign prosecutors will have the nerve, reflexes and independence to make arrests – but there are some, like the Spaniard Baltasar Garzón who might take a shot. If justice is ever to be done, it will have to be by Americans.
Update 28 October
Larry Johnson, blogging at TPM Café (after me) on the same subject, adds the point that if arrest warrants are issued, some of them will themselves have international reach. If a French prosecutor issued a European arrest warrant for Rumsfeld, he wouldn’t be safe even in politically sympathetic EU countries like Poland.